Women's Health

Which is safer, prescription BHRT or OTC herbal hormones?

Get informed before making a decision on the type of hormone replacement therapy is right for you.
Dr. Nayan Patel
PharmD

Hormone therapy can be a game-changer for individuals seeking to manage symptoms associated with hormonal imbalances, such as menopause or andropause. When exploring hormone therapy options, you'll encounter two main choices: prescription bioidentical hormone replacement therapy (BHRT) and over-the-counter hormone creams. In this article, we'll delve into the key differences between these two options and highlight the advantages of choosing bioidentical hormones over OTC hormone creams.

Understanding Hormone Therapy

Before we dive into the differences, let's clarify what hormone therapy is and why it's important. Hormone therapy involves supplementing or replacing hormones in the body, typically when natural hormone production declines with age or due to a medical condition. This therapy aims to alleviate symptoms and improve overall well-being.

Over-the-Counter Hormone Creams

OTC hormone creams are widely available and are marketed as convenient solutions for managing hormonal imbalances. These creams are often plant derived extracts that would mimic the effects of natural hormones but are not identical to human hormones.  

Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT): The Prescription Option

On the other hand, BHRT, available only through a healthcare provider's prescription, uses hormones that are structurally identical to the hormones naturally produced by your body. These hormones are derived from plant sources and are specifically compounded to match your individual hormonal needs.

Key Differences between OTC Hormone Creams and BHRT:

1. Hormone Structure: The most significant difference lies in the structure of the hormones used. BHRT hormones are bioidentical, meaning they are molecularly identical to the hormones your body produces. OTC creams, on the other hand, often contain herbal hormones, which may have different effects on your body's receptors and can lead to side effects.

2. Customization: BHRT is tailored to each individual based on their hormone levels, symptoms, and overall health. Your healthcare provider will prescribe specific hormone combinations and dosages to address your unique needs. OTC creams offer a one-size-fits-all approach, which may not be effective for everyone. Hormone therapy requires delicate balancing of all hormones easily achievable by custom compounding for individual patients. 

3. Regulation and Safety: Prescription BHRT is subject to rigorous regulation and oversight by healthcare authorities, ensuring safety, quality, and effectiveness. OTC creams may not undergo the same level of scrutiny, potentially leading to inconsistencies in hormone concentration and purity.

Benefits of BHRT Over OTC Hormone Creams:

1. Hormonal Balance: BHRT, being bioidentical, is more likely to help you achieve and maintain hormonal balance, reducing symptoms like hot flashes, mood swings, and low libido.

2. Reduced Side Effects: BHRT is associated with fewer side effects compared to OTC creams that contain herbal hormones. Herbal hormones can lead to unwanted effects like bloating, breast tenderness, mood disturbances and may not address the real issue.

3. Customized Treatment: With BHRT, your healthcare provider can customize your treatment to address your specific hormonal imbalances and needs, ensuring a more effective and tailored approach to hormone therapy.

4. Safety and Reliability: BHRT is compounded in licensed facilities in the USA that adheres to strict quality and safety standards, providing confidence in the purity and consistency of the product.

5. Comprehensive Health Support: BHRT, when prescribed as part of a broader treatment plan, can address complex health issues beyond just symptom management, such as bone health and cardiovascular health.

6. Long-Term Benefits: BHRT offers a sustainable solution to hormonal imbalances, supporting your overall health and well-being over the long term.

In conclusion, choosing between over-the-counter hormone creams and prescription bioidentical hormone replacement therapy is a significant decision with far-reaching implications for your health and quality of life. While OTC options may appear more accessible, they come with potential risks and limitations, including the use of non-identical hormones and lack of customization.

Prescription BHRT, on the other hand, provides a safer, more effective, and personalized approach to achieving hormonal balance. When considering hormone therapy, it's essential to consult with a healthcare provider who can guide you towards the best and safest options for your specific needs. Remember, investing in your health and well-being is a decision that can pay dividends in terms of your quality of life.

References

Restoring Hormonal Balance After Hysterectomy (Surgical Menopause)
Restoring Hormonal Balance After Hysterectomy (Surgical Menopause)
If your ovaries were removed or compromised as part of a hysterectomy, it’s likely that a doctor will prescribe hormone replacement.
Read More
The Pill's Usage Can Deplete Vital Nutrients in the Body
The Pill's Usage Can Deplete Vital Nutrients in the Body
While the pill offers benefits for contraception, it's essential to address the potential nutrient depletions it may cause.
Read More
10 Signs of High Testosterone in Women‎ ‎ ‎ ‎
10 Signs of High Testosterone in Women‎ ‎ ‎ ‎
If you’re dealing with acne, excess facial hair, and irregular periods, high testosterone could be to blame. Read on to discover more w
Read More
How Optimized Hormone Levels Can Help Improve Your Libido.
How Optimized Hormone Levels Can Help Improve Your Libido.
If your hormones are unbalanced, your libido dips. Learn what hormones affect libido and how optimizing your hormone health can help.
Read More
Which is safer, prescription BHRT or OTC herbal hormones?
Which is safer, prescription BHRT or OTC herbal hormones?
Choosing between over-the-counter hormone creams and prescription bioidentical hormone replacement therapy is a significant decision.
Read More
Hormones and Sleep: What's the Connection for your Sleep Cycle?
Hormones and Sleep: What's the Connection for your Sleep Cycle?
Hormones play an important role in regulating your sleep cycle — but how?
Read More

GET STARTED

Reclaim Your Hormone Balance

Take the first step to feel your best with our free eligibility quiz.